Example email
Where I’d start and what can wait
I’ve been thinking about the story you told me over the phone. You were at the stove finishing dinner when everyone at the table started laughing. By the time you set the food down, you’d missed the story. What stayed with me was how much you enjoy cooking for your friends. You want to keep doing that and still be close enough to look up, catch a friend’s eye, and laugh along. I’m glad you told me that. It helped me understand what you’re hoping a more open kitchen would give you.
I’m glad we talked about an ordinary Tuesday, too. Being able to finish dinner and set the table together without one of you having to stop and move matters in its own right. I’d keep both evenings in mind as you decide how much of the house you want to change.
You asked thoughtful questions about the wall, who to call first, what you’d feel comfortable spending, and what to look for before you sign a proposal. I’ve gathered those questions below so you can come back to each one when it’s useful. For this week, there’s one thing I’d start with together.
Now
Get clear on what each of you wants to feel different at home
Here’s the one thing I’d do this week. Pick a dinner you both remember. Take five minutes each and finish this thought in a few sentences: “It’s ten minutes before we eat. If the kitchen worked the way I wanted, here’s what I’d be able to do.” Then read what you wrote to each other. Listen for one detail in the other person’s version that you hadn’t pictured. Write those two details down together, and call it done.
It reminded me of replacing the couches in our own living room. We spent some time thinking about how our family actually likes to sit, relax, and gather. That changed which couches we chose. I’m an architect, and one of the most useful changes we made at home involved moving exactly zero walls.
Next
Use those details to sort out scope, people, and money
“Is this a kitchen remodel, or are we taking on the dining room, too?”
You said you’d be happy to keep the dining room as it is if you could still see and talk to the people sitting there. That gives you a useful question for a designer: “What could we improve by working within the kitchen, and what would changing the dining room make possible?” Then you can decide whether including another room gives you something you care enough about to pay for.
“Who should we talk to first, and when can we get a cost we can trust?”
For the question you’re facing, I’d start with a designer who can help you compare ways to make the kitchen work. When you talk to someone you might hire, I’d tell them exactly what you told me: “We’re worried we’ll fall in love with a design and only then find out what it costs. When do you bring a contractor into that conversation?” Listen for when you’d see an initial estimate, what it would be based on, and whether you’d still have room to change direction. Their answer will tell you something about how it would feel to work with them.
“How do we set a budget if we might finance part of it?”
I heard two questions in that one. What might the work cost? And what would we feel comfortable committing, given everything else we want to do with our money? Your project team can help you explore the first as the scope takes shape. If borrowing affects the second, an early conversation with your lender can help you decide what range you’re comfortable exploring. It’s worth knowing that about yourselves before the larger kitchen-and-dining-room option starts to feel like the plan.
Later
Come back to these questions when you have something in front of you
“What should we look for in a design proposal before we sign?”
You had two specific concerns I’d carry forward: what you’ll receive for the fee, and what happens if the first layout doesn’t work for you. When you have a written proposal, ask the designer to walk you through one example: “Say we look at the first layout and realize we want to keep the dining room after all. What happens next? Which revisions are included, and when would an additional fee begin?” That gives you both a concrete way to understand what you’d be agreeing to before you sign.
“Do we need to settle the island question before we meet anyone?”
You can leave that one open. Keep the photo you both liked and make a note of the detail that caught your eye: a friend could pull up a stool and talk to the cook while dinner was on. When you eventually look at a layout, picture that friend on the stool. Then picture a Tuesday night and open the dishwasher. It deserves a vote, too.
For this week, I’d just do the dinner exercise. The rest of this email is here so that when it’s time to call a designer or look at a proposal, you won’t have to remember, “What was that thing we wanted to ask?”
And if one of you reads this and thinks I gave the dinner parties too much weight and Tuesday nights too little, hit reply and tell me. I’d want to know.
Jason